.
Feedback

Columbus Remains Controversial Figure

Columbus Day: a day for controversy or celebration? I answer that question here for me...what say you?

Christopher Columbus has become a controversial figure of late. When I was a kid, we sang about and celebrated his discovery of America. You remember:  "Columbus sailed the ocean blue, fourteen-hundred-ninety-two..."  Permemnently etched in my brain are teh names of his three ships -- the Nina, the Pinta and Santa Maria.  I was actually surprised to see that Melissa Gorga, of Real Housewives of New Jersey fame (the show is a huge guilty pleasure of mine), remembered the ships' names, too.  Columbus Day was a simple, innocent holiday back then.

Now there is a need to qualify Christopher Columbus's journey and discovery with his being a product of the times he lived in. Yes, he was motivated by money rather than simply the desire to discover.  No, he didn't ever make it to the United States mainland, just to Puerto Rico (a place I wouldn't mind landing -- talk about a happy accident!).  Yes, he was freaked out by the natives of the strange land he landed upon and acted according to the societal norms of the day.  It's probably not in the cards for me to leave the legacy Christopher Columbus did but we all leave our mark on the world.  I hope the things I said and did during my life are taken upon their own merits and not judged so harshly because of the age in which I live by my great-great-grandkids.

Regardless of anything else, I think that we can all agree -- old school and new school -- that although the mission Christopher Columbus embarked upon failed, he proved the world was round and vast...and forever changed it, making the mission ultimately a success.

The biggest personal impact I feel from Columbus is this: He said "I will" when everyone said "You can't" and then he did it anyway. Important lessons indeed and ones I draw upon daily.

Happy Columbus Day! If you are Italian-American, celebrate the pride of your culture and the bravery of one of your ancestors!  If you are simply American, celebrate the groundwork for the American Spirit!  If you are neither, enjoy the gorgeous day that nature gave Long Island today.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from West Islip Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Catherine Artusa May 25, 2013 at 05:12 pm
I have to say the most disturbing part of this is we are talking about high school students notRead More criminals. With all the media surrounding them, mistakes or these types of things are bound to happen. Its for the parents to handle, not the public. Its a personal matter. Anyone who is going against these kids has major issues and should really look in the mirror at their own mistakes. I agree that this has nothing to do with West Islip or the school board. That is ridiculous!!!
Valerie May 25, 2013 at 03:32 pm
my point exactly!
Scott May 25, 2013 at 03:30 pm
The media was called by the person who turned the kids in. This person fed the media falseRead More information, claiming that the incident was more severe then it was. In the aftermath of the glen cove cheating story, the media was crawling all over town looking to break a scandle. In my opinion, the superintendent did the right thing by issuing a statement. It was a really dumb story to begin with, and it is one thing to alert the school principal about the issue, nothing wrong with that, but to turn around and call the coakaroach media in means that that person was looking to hurt the students and damage the school district. I wonder who would be so calculating, so full of hatred for the schools and administration to stoop to that level? Maybe the answer to that question is really what you are seeking.
Paul May 24, 2013 at 10:38 am
Yes, I was also really disappointed to see the damage to the sign on Lion's Path. Some people haveRead More no respect.
West Islip Resident May 25, 2013 at 11:23 am
Is it me? Or does anyone else think that all parties involved should be fired for betraying theRead More trust and adding to the tarnished reputation the West Islip School system and its students by reporting the recent cheating scandal to the media. I mean really, did anyone from the district or school system need to contribute to the story in the media, how about no comment the matter is under review. Why does the BOE allow an overpaid moron like Richard Simon with no public information experience to speak to the media let alone anyone? This matter should have been handled by the School Districts attorney. Good job to the Morons of the BOE and Superintendents office keep letting us tax payers down.
MomWI May 25, 2013 at 09:47 am
well, that makes more sense...I was shocked when I read that headline, as I am continuallyRead More underwhelmed by this district. thanks for clarifying.
Rita May 24, 2013 at 02:29 pm
Typical misleading info from West Islip school district!
West Islip Beach and Marina
Opinion  

1   Recommend J.B.

West Islip Beach and Marina
ELLA May 24, 2013 at 03:58 pm
Beautiful picture. Would like to post it on my Facebook timeline. If not OK, please post.
West Islip Resident May 18, 2013 at 07:23 pm
You can thank all these POS politicians for the new gun legislation designed to make law abidingRead More citizens give up their second amendment rights out of sheer frustration and incontinence of owning a gun legally for increases in savage on citizen violence. This is only the beginning and in short time many New Yorker's will be forced to remain in their homes fearing one of these animals will make them their pray. I for one believe in the old adage, it's better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6.
ARNOLD MERKITCH May 17, 2013 at 07:34 pm
WREATH LAYING FOR 9/11 BEAM WILL BE APPROXIMATELY 11AM ON 5/2713